Scare your little trick or treaters with these naturally green peanut butter wicked witch finger cookies!
Witch Fingers
You can’t taste the spinach in these biscuits at all, but it makes them a wonderfully spooky green colour – like the wicked witch in The Wizard of Oz!
I’ve added peanut butter so although they look spooky, they just taste like peanut butter cookies dipped in jam.
These witch fingers are super easy to make and fun to make with kids!
Easily vegan and gluten free. See notes in recipe card for tips.
Halloween Party
I’ve absolutely loved Halloween since I was small.
We lived in Canada and my mum was a bit paranoid and didn’t like to let me and my sister go trick or treating, so she threw amazing over-the-top parties instead.
We had a cassette (showing my age here) of scary sounds that played out to passers-by. We had a dressed up witch who sat on the front porch and fake cobwebs everywhere.
There were bowls of eyeballs (peeled grapes), toenails (flaked almonds), brains (cooked spaghetti) etc… all laid out for daring trick or treaters to touch in the dark, as well as the usual sweets and candies.
And the food, wow. My parents would lay out an amazing spread of spooky homemade food. We would have loved to have these scary witch fingers!
Halloween Party Food
Inside, my parents would bake piles of biscuits, cookies, cakes and other spooky treats for us all to devour as we partied in our fancy dress outfits.
These Halloween Mummy Pies would have been perfect. For something savory, turn bread rolls into the shape of snakes, spiders and other creatures with my recipe for easy bread shapes.
Now that my kids are old enough to enjoy the fun of Halloween, I’ve been enjoying cooking up scary foods for them as well.
These witch finger cookies are a bit of a Pinterest sensation and I’ve been making them for a few years now.
This year I thought I’d go back to my vegetable desserts roots and make them green – with spinach! Don’t worry, you can’t taste the spinach – it just gives them the colour.
Making Witch Finger Cookies
These witch finger biscuits are super easy to make, and kids will love helping.
I made these ones a bit extra-gruesome with the blood (raspberry jam) and my kids loved them – though they were a bit grossed out as they ate them – perfect! Got to love an easy recipe that’s perfect for a Halloween party!
Cook’s Tips:
- Puree the spinach well so it gets a nice even colour. Aim for it to puree to a thick paste.
- Make it vegan: use dairy free butter/spread/margarine
- Make it gluten-free: use gluten-free flour
Get the spooky Halloween Witch Fingers recipe
Naturally Green Witch Finger Cookies
Ingredients
- 100 g - 2 cups - raw spinach
- 75 g - 1/3 cup - unsalted butter , softened
- 50 g - 1/4 cup - smooth peanut butter
- 50 g - ¼ cup - caster sugar
- 1 teaspoon almond extract
- 225 g -2 cups - plain (all purpose) flour
To decorate:
- Almond flakes/slices
- Seedless raspberry jam
Instructions
- Wilt the spinach in a saucepan with a small amount of boiling water, then run under cold water to refresh, squeeze out the moisture, chop up the spinach then puree it with a hand held stick blender until smooth. (NOTE: make it really smooth in order to get a good green colour)
- Beat the butter, peanut butter and sugar together until smooth and fluffy. Add in the spinach puree and almond extract and beat well. Sift in the flour and mix.
- Turn the mixture onto a lightly floured surface and knead until it forms a soft dough. Wrap in clingfilm and chill in the fridge for 30 minutes.
- Preheat oven to 180C/350F. Line a baking tray with baking paper.
- Roll tablespoonfuls of the dough into 4” long finger shapes and gently press the sides to create knuckles.
- Use a knife to cut horizontal ridges for knuckles. Press an almond slice into the end of each finger.
- Place the fingers onto the prepared baking tray and bake for 15 minutes or until the edges begin to turn very slightly golden.
- Allow to cool for 5 minutes on the tray and then transfer to a wire rack to cool completely.
- Dip the ends in the raspberry jam to create the look of severed fingers.
Recipe Tips
- Make it vegan: use dairy free butter
- Make it gluten-free: use gluten free flour
Nutrition Information
Thanks for checking out my Witch Fingers recipe! I love hearing from my readers. You all allow me to do what I love and write this UK food blog, sharing vegetarian and vegan recipes, vegetable cake recipes and also easy vegan desserts.
Kate x
Demeter
These are ghoulishly perfect for Halloween! Love that they’re a healthier twist too.
Claudia Lamascolo
this is so creative, I made fingers last year and I love the red blood on these are perfect! I will try that!
Shashi at SavorySpin
These are just too too cool! Loving the coloring from the spinach and what a fantastic take on PB&J eh?!
Danielle Wolter
These are so fun for Halloween! what a great idea. isn’t it great how peanut butter can mask stuff like spinach?
Claire
So clever using spinach for the green and I LOVE anything with peanut butter. I made these for the kids to take to the village halloween party and everyone thought they were very scary.
Liza
I absolutely and utterly loved these! I made them for my kids and they were almost too scared to eat them. Tasty though!
Jan
These were so fun and scary. Thanks for the recipe they tasted really good and looked so frightening. I’ll be making them every year for sure!
Izzy
I made them with my son for hallowe’en and we had so much fun. I did the spinach though and then sneaked it in so he didn’t see. I didn’t want him not to eat them (he is 5). But he loved them. We made them a little bit less scary. Everyone at the party loved the fingers. Thank you
Claire
Is the peanut butter missing? Or am I missing something?
Kate Hackworthy
Oops, correct version posted now! 🙂
Claire
Thank you! I’m glad I asked. Really fancy making these.
Julia @ HappyFoods Tube
Wow! Amazing job! They look like real! 🙂
Ana
These witch finger cookies look perfect for Haloween. I am sure kids are going to love this!
NOM NOM Boris
OMG this is so amazingly disturbing!!! Love it. Would make a perfect Halloween snack. This is crazy and kind of healthy ahhaah
Becca
I LOVE these – so simple but so effective! And I love that you managed to get your veggies in 😀
Kavey
Love these, I’ve seen spooky fingers on Pinterest but yours look so much more ghoulish and love that they are naturally coloured too.
Lisa
These are awesome! I know my 11 year old granddaughter would love them! Maybe she and I can make them together!
Ali - We Made This Life
Wow these are something special! They look fantastic! I definitely want to make these for our halloween party this year!
Sarah, Things Sarah Loves
Oh my goodness how amazing do these look?!! I love peanut butter and these are perfect for Halloween.
Karly
Ha ha ha they look so freaky but I bet they are delicious!
Rosana @ Hot&CHilli Food and Travel Blog
Brilliant! Love the attention to detail on this fingers! Well done. R
Platter Talk
I love this idea for a Halloween treat!!! They are so gross looking but sound so tasty. Our kids are going to love these!
Thanks.
Tara
Such great looking fingers! Love the addition of spinach to make them naturally green. Definitely perfect for Halloween.